FLASHBACK 2023: Herald TV debates burning issues that affect Goan lives

It is ironical that despite being the smallest State of the country, in terms of geographical area, Goa is grappling with multiple issues. In 2023, Herald TV in its weekly debate Point-Counterpoint took up these issues for discussion, which ranged from double tracking, coal transportation, poor road conditions in Smart City Panjim, road accidents, threat to Goa’s ecology from Mhadei river diversion by Karnataka, sex trafficking, deteriorating tourism quality and many such critical issues that affected the lives of peace loving Goenkars. As the year comes to an end, O Heraldo looks back at the key topics taken up by Herald TV for debate in 2023
FLASHBACK 2023: Herald TV debates burning issues that affect Goan lives
Published on

Road accidents

Cocktail of drunken driving & overspeeding emerges as new life threat on Goa’s roads - 13 Aug 2023 

In a dastardly tragedy that occurred on the Banastarim bridge recently, a very high-end Mercedes SUV driven crushed three persons under its wheels, including a couple from Divar island. While it is not yet known who was driving the car, but the front seats were occupied by Paresh Sawardekar and his wife Meghna. The driver was allegedly intoxicated and as the car approached the bridge, it swerved and took in its wake about two or three vehicles, motorcycle riders and their pillions, leaving behind a trail of blood, gore and death of three innocent lives for no reason at all. There are three people who are struggling for life and even if they survive, their condition is such that they might end up being living dead, where life would literally have no meaning. In the middle of it is a larger narrative of a high-end car driven by very rich people and powerful persons with absolute and clear-cut connections with people in power and having the support of legal, political and the business fraternity. The entire tragedy has once again shocked the entire State, which not very long ago saw a similar car accident on the Zuari bridge, that killed all the four passengers in the car and like the Banastarim tragedy, the occupants of the car were also returning from a party and were allegedly drunk. There are also allegations of a botched-up investigation by police in an attempt to protect the real accused, since the person belongs to an influential family of Goa. In the weekly Herald TV debate, Point-Counterpoint, SUJAY GUPTA digs deep to find out the impact of this tragedy, the menace of drunken driving and the truth behind the allegations of police deliberately trying to mislead the investigation

Goa: Where ‘one-for-the-road’ kills too many - 19 Nov 2023

As the world gears up to observe Remembrance Day for road traffic victims, a solemn occasion recognised by the United Nations, our focus turns to the pressing issue that hits close to home in Goa. The number of road accidents is on the rise, a trend that demands urgent attention and concerted efforts. As we mourn the dead, we must equally grieve for the living, whose lives are marred by crushed bones, lost livelihoods, and a future dependent on others. In Herald TV’s numerous meetings to dissect the patterns, extent and challenges surrounding road mishaps, a glaring concern emerges — accidents, particularly those involving drunken and substance-induced driving, are escalating. The suspicion that intoxicated drivers are often at the wheel during late-night or early-morning accidents cannot be ignored. It’s crucial to shift our focus to the ground realities. In this week’s debate Point-Counterpoint, panelists speak about what are needed as a society to address this menace head-on. By implementing effective deterrents, ensuring sustainable transport systems, and fostering collaboration among different entities, we can strive to make our roads safer and protect the lives of those who call Goa home

======

UnSmart Panjim city

Is Panjim city everything but ‘smart’?  - - 05 Mar 2023

The manner in which the Corporation of City of Panaji (CCP) has undertaken various works under Smart City Mission has been drawing flak from the citizens, who are irked due to road closures, making it difficult to travel in the city. There are road blockades at every intersection as CCP is in a tearing hurry to complete the projects before the June 2023 deadline given by the Union Ministry of Urban Development. The people of Panjim are struggling currently with ongoing Smart City works. The commuters everyday face a lot of hardships caused by the damaged roads and traffic snarls caused by the incessant digging for Smart City projects. The chaos caused by the dug-up roads is causing severe stress to not only the local residents of Panjim, but also visitors, especially tourists. Herald TV finds out the reasons for this mess

=====

Tourism

GOA TOURISM: HAVE WE KILLED THE GOLDEN GOOSE? - - 24 Dec 2023 

Whenever we speak about Goa, the first thing that comes to our mind is tourism. But recently, the word tourism is evoking less of joy and more of worry. The tourism industry in Goa is taking a beating every year. The government is trying its best to attract high spending tourists, but succeeds in getting only low-end spenders. The exploitation of Goa’s pristine nature and its brand as a favourite destination to maximise revenue collection has only made the matters worse. The tourism industry contributes about 17% towards the State GDP and benefits an influential section of the population. The full focus of attracting tourists has been on gambling, fun and party time events. Drugs and sex are an integral part of that trade. Goa failed to promote quality tourism sustainable in the long run in a tint state. In the weekly Herald TV debate Point-Counterpoint, we find out what is going wrong with the tourism sector in Goa, whether due to the teething issues plaguing the industry, brand Goa has taken a beating and what can be done to resurrect the image of Goa as a tourism destination. The moot question that needs to be answered is, have we killed the Golden Goose, which is tourism?

=====

FISHING

Goans fishing in troubled waters as they continue to grapple with multiple challenges - 08 Oct 2023 

Goa, located on the western coast of India, is blessed with an abundance of marine resources. Fishing has been a traditional occupation in Goa, and seafood is an integral part of the local cuisine. Fish is one of the most important natural resources of the world and holds greater importance to the state of Goa being an integral part of Goan life and culture. It is considered as a staple diet for more than 90 percent of the population of Goa. Goa shares nearly two per cent of the total marine fish production of our country. The marine fisheries sector contributes to about three percent of the state GDP and 17 percent of the agricultural GDP. Thus the fisheries industry plays a vital role in the State’s socio-economic development. However, the rapid increase in population, tourism, and demand for seafood has put immense pressure on the marine resources leading to overfishing and depletion of fish stocks. The problems faced by the fisheries sector in Goa are multi-faceted. However, the fisheries sector of the State faces various challenges like over-exploitation, indiscriminate fishing practices, fish migration barriers, pollution, habitat degradation, invasive species, climate change and lack of proper management. We analyse the problems faced by the fishing community in Goa and the long-term implications of these issues

===

Mhadei river diversion and tiger reserve 

Mhadei diversion: Goa stares at environmental catastrophe  - 22 Jan 2023

Central Water Commission’s (CWC) nod to the Karnataka government’s detailed project report (DPR) for the construction of dams on Mhadei river which will lead to diversion of Mhadei river water into Karnataka, has left every Goan angry and worried about their future since it will have far reaching implications on the overall environment of Goa. Herald TV assesses the potential loss that could be caused to ecology and its cascading effect on the people of Goa by the CWC’s decision to the Karnataka government’s DPR for the Kalasa-Bandura project and what lies ahead for Goa, which has been let down by its own political leadership as well as in the Centre, despite the fact that Goa, Karnataka and the Centre are all governed by the BJP

Tiger will protect the Forest; forest shall guard the tiger! - 31 Jul 2023

The High Court of Bombay at Goa recently directed the State government to notify the Mhadei Wildlife Sanctuary and other areas referred to in National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA)’s communications as a Tiger Reserve under Section 38-V (1) of the Wildlife Protection Act (WLPA) within three months from the date of the order. In a damning order which has embarrassed and indicted the State government for flouting Supreme Court orders, the High Court pointed out that the State of Goa has defied SC timelines and directives to settle the rights of forest dwellers and used this delay as an excuse for not notifying the tiger reserve. The Court also directed the State government to take all steps to prepare a tiger conservation plan as contemplated by Section 38-V (3) of the WLPA. It also directed to forward the same to the NTCA within three months of notifying the Mhadei Wildlife Sanctuary and other areas as a Tiger Reserve. Herald TV deliberates on the impact of this order and whether it will help in protecting the forest and the Mhadei river water

-----

DOUBLE TRACKING

Beyond double tracking: When Goan lives are derailed - 15 Jan 2023 

The locals and social activists are up in arms as they feel that the double tracking project of the South Western Railways (SWR), which is being executed by the Rail Vikas Nigam Limited (RVNL), is invading into the private properties and lands of Goans. As a media organisation, Herald has been crusading against this issue relentlessly. The railway authorities need to explain to the people of Goa as to what gives them the entitlement to get into the private lands, under the garb of building embankments to raise the height of the land adjoining the proposed double tracking work, which is going on, especially through the thickly populated villages like Majorda and Cansaulim, amongst others. We explore the concerns surrounding the toll that is being taken on the lives of Goans by the double tracking project and its future implications as there seems to be an attempt for another round of land acquisition, this time illegally

Can Railways carry out double tracking work without survey numbers in place? - 11 Jun 2023

The South Western Railways (SWR) is literally bulldozing its way through the terrain of coastal South Goa, especially the upper coastal South Goa, in its quest to carry out the double tracking of the SWR from Majorda to Vasco. The villages of Cansaulim, Velsao, Chicalim, Issorcim, Pale and Arossim are badly affected. The SWR has actually been carrying out its work of double tracking with no survey numbers in place and recently after a lot of pressure and a lot of noise by very committed people, the Revenue Department decided to do a survey across 25 villages to ascertain the actual survey numbers to authenticate the final ownership and the presence of the Railways in those particular lands. We evaluate the latest developments in the double tracking saga and what does it entail for the future of Goa

-------------

Land acquisition

Face-off with the State over land acquisition ruining lives of people and putting their future in peril -03 Sep 2023

Residents of Bhoma village in Ponda taluka recently staged a protest against the proposed expansion plan of the existing National Highway (NH), expressing concerns over the impact on their village and temples. Despite an agitation for a bypass leading to the cancellation of the NH expansion plan in 2012, the project has been revived, contradicting the Regional Plan. On the other hand, Velsao villagers refused to surrender their land for the rail double tracking project. The villagers have conveyed their resentments against the Government of Goa and criticised the authorities for not even intervening to protect the interest of the locals against the consistent threats from Rail Vikas Nigam Limited (RVNL) to deny them the right to reside in their homeland. The villagers have vowed not to give up their land no matter what. Herald TV joins these two important developments together in the Herald TV weekly debate Point-Counterpoint and finds out such face-off between the people and State administration over land acquisition for the so-called development projects is presently ruining people’s lives and puts their future at risk

GOA’s MUNDKARS: A prolonged fight for protecting their land & identity - 05 Nov 2023

When the State government passed the Goa Bhumiputra Bill in 2021, wherein even migrants residing in the houses for 30 years were to be granted ownership rights, being the original bhumiputras; tenants and mundkars in Goa, fighting for years to get their right under Agriculture Tenancy Act and Mundkar Act, urged the government to look into their grievances first. The existence of Mundkars is completely linked to Goa’s land and the existence of people, who’ve been working on this land and living on it for generations. While this whole issue of Tenancy and the Mundkar Act and its associated problems have been doing the rounds for a very long time, unfortunately all that has happened is just pure lip service in trying to sort out the issues of the tenants. There are people fighting for years to get rights to the properties that their forefathers had. Recently in the Pernem taluka, these issues have surfaced at Mopa. Lot of land has been sold and transferred to persons without taking them into consideration. Denying land to the tenants is the biggest betrayal of the mundkars. The leaders who became what they are today through their participation in the Kul-Mundkar movement, are keeping quiet. We evaluate the issues revolving the mundkars and what’s in store for them

=====

Domestic violence, 10 Dec 2023 

A ‘PARADISE’ VIOLATED: Goa's domestic violence explosion hits hard

If the issue of sexual abuse of women in Goa wasn’t enough, there is another social evil harming our women, which is domestic violence. According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5), around 20 per cent of the surveyed women (aged 18-49 years) had experienced either physical or sexual violence, and three per cent had experienced both. Overall, eight per cent of women, who were or had ever been married, reported experiencing violence from their spouses. Only 10 per cent of the women who had experienced physical or sexual violence sought help. Total 189 domestic violence cases in Goa were reported to the Block Development Officers in 2022. In a vapour cloud explosion incident on November 18, at New Vaddem in Vasco, a pregnant woman named Shivani Rajawat and her mother Jaidevi were killed. Brother of Shivani Rajawat has filed a complaint before the Sub Divisional Magistrate of Mormugao, accusing his brother-in-law Anurag Rajawat, husband of Shivani, for allegedly planning the murder and also against Anurag’s mother for her alleged role in dowry harassment. Herald TV finds out why domestic violence is a worrying situation and its long-term implications

==

Human trafficking, 17 Sep 2023 

Menace of human trafficking continues unabated in Goa defying all laws

The Anjuna Police recently busted an international sex trafficking ring, operating between Kenya and India and arrested two Kenyans. The police also rescued five victims from Kenya. A Nigerian national who is involved in the racket, who was absconding, has been arrested. The rescued women have been lodged in the Protective Home at Merces. This incident is a grim reminder of the fact that Goa continues to be a major destination for sex trafficking. There are traffickers who are both from the country and internationally who are operating with absolute nonchalance, which is totally baffling. What is critical here is that there seems to be a complete lack of coordination between different law and order agencies to prevent trafficking.

-------------

Portuguese passport  - 03 Dec 2023 

Portuguese Passports for Goans: Brace for the new challenges lying ahead

Over the last one year, the Goa Passport Office has been revoking approximately one passport out of 15-20 sent to its office for surrendering the same. Following a communication dated November 30, 2022, from the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) and Portuguese authorities, indicating that citizenship is acquired upon birth registration in Portugal, the Regional Passport Office, Panjim initiated the revocation process on the basis that the MEA is now using the birth registration date in Portugal as the citizenship acquisition date. Typically, Indian passport reissues or renewals aim to correct names for submission to Portuguese authorities, facilitating Portuguese citizenship. Previously, obtaining a Portuguese passport or acquiring a Bilhete de Identidade (identity card) determined foreign nationality acquisition. Now, it hinges on the date of birth registration in Portugal. If a passport is revoked during surrender, one cannot apply for an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) card, making them a foreign national, who has to, in turn, obtain legal permission for being in the country. This action did not go down well among a large section of Goans, who have criticised this move.

-----------------

Rottweiler issue - 27 Aug 2023 

Untrained and unleashed canines spread terror on the streets of Goa

An evening walk turned out to be a nightmare for two siblings aged between five and seven years as they were brutally mauled by a Rottweiler in a horrific incident reported in an elite colony at Shivnagar-Alto-Oaitiyant, Taleigao recently. The ferocious dog managed to get out of the compound of a bungalow and pounced on the little kids brutally attacking them. The boy sustained facial injuries including his ear and also injuries to his chest, while the Rottweiler sunk his canines deep into the girl’s skull and neck. The kids were out on an evening walk along with their mother when the horrible incident unfolded. The helpless mother could do nothing much to save her little ones from the beast. While the police booked the owner of the Rottweiler, the incident has spread terror throughout Goa. Herald TV deliberates on the double whammy caused by lack of awareness regarding regulations governing the management of such pets on one hand and inadequate number of dog trainers on the other

Herald Goa
www.heraldgoa.in